Rep. Elise Stefanik, the third-ranking House Republican, criticized the Biden administration when proposed modifications to a federal meals program for ladies and kids grew to become public.
“The Biden Administration’s proposal to limit the quantity of milk obtainable to WIC members is incorrect,” Stefanik mentioned in a information launch.
Stefanik represents a geographically giant district in New York’s North Nation, and most of the state’s nearly 3,600 dairy farms are in her district.
She referred to as the proposed modifications “deeply flawed” and mentioned that the administration “is shamefully additional proscribing milk selection for households and preserving the door open for extra compelled vegan juice consumption. Upstate dairy farmers work exhausting to offer scrumptious and nutritious merchandise for households in New York and throughout the nation, and this proposed rule is a slap within the face to their necessary work.”
Persons are additionally studying…
Stefanik continuously finds fault with the Biden administration, and we puzzled if her declare over milk was appropriate.
The Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children, or WIC, supplies wholesome meals, diet schooling, breastfeeding help and referrals to well being care suppliers and social providers for low-income girls, infants and kids up till their fifth birthday. In 2020, this system served about 7 million people. Diet help is supplied in packages particular to every inhabitants this system serves: pregnant girls, postpartum girls, infants, youngsters, and so forth.
The proposed modifications to this system replicate each up to date dietary tips, printed in 2020, and a 2017 report from the Nationwide Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Drugs, a nongovernmental group of main consultants that gives unbiased evaluation and evidence-based recommendation.
The changes have been detailed within the Federal Register. The proposal requires lowering the quantity of milk supplied in all youngster, pregnant and breastfeeding participant meals packages. The quantity for postpartum girls would stay unchanged.
In comparison with present most month-to-month allowances for milk, youngsters, relying on age, would obtain 2 to 4 fewer quarts monthly. Pregnant and principally breastfeeding members would obtain 6 fewer quarts monthly, whereas absolutely breastfeeding members would obtain 8 fewer quarts monthly. The proposed rule additionally requires a brand new package deal particularly for 1-year-olds, who’re grouped with older youngsters below the present guidelines. Underneath the brand new tips, 1-year-olds would get lower than youngsters ages 2 to 4.
The reason for the modifications, in line with the U.S. Division of Agriculture, which administers the WIC program by means of its Meals and Diet Service, is that the present program supplies quantities as much as 128% of the every day really useful quantity of dairy. The Nationwide Academies suggested the quantity of milk allowed in this system ought to be diminished to between 71% and 96% of the really useful quantity.
The proposed portions are per diet tips to eat a balanced weight loss plan that meets, however doesn’t exceed, really useful quantities of meals and vitamins, to forestall weight problems and to not displace different wholesome meals, in line with the Federal Register discover.
The change is “modest,” and represents only a 3% discount in WIC spending on milk and milk alternate options, USDA Press Secretary Marissa Perry informed PolitiFact.
“WIC’s meals packages are designed to be supplemental, filling particular dietary gaps, constructing on what members already eat to offer a balanced and nutritious weight loss plan,” Perry mentioned. The discount permits the packages to offer a greater steadiness of meals and diet, she mentioned.
Shannon E. Whaley was vice chair of the Nationwide Academies committee that printed recommendations for proposed modifications and can be director of analysis and analysis on the nonprofit Public Well being Basis Enterprise WIC Program. Whaley emphasised the supplemental nature of this system, and added the quantity of milk that members have been buying by means of this system was lower than what was allotted. “Due to this fact, the report recommends a small calibration of the quantity of milk issued, however at a stage nonetheless above the common quantity redeemed,” Whaley mentioned.
We requested Stefanik’s workplace about her declare that the suggestions open the door to extra “compelled vegan juice consumption.”
“Because it says within the proposed rule, the USDA is preserving the door open to the provision of different plant-based drinks (e.g., oat, almond),” mentioned Stefanik’s spokesperson Palmer Brigham. “Coupled with proposing proscribing milk, this reveals the transfer in direction of extra vegan juice consumption.”
A WIC researcher on the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg Faculty of Public Well being, Susan Gross, mentioned that WIC program members have numerous wants, resembling meals allergic reactions or being vegan, and they don’t drink milk from cows. Program directors wish to discover whether or not different alternate options may be provided. Lactose-free milk and soy milk have at all times been a part of this system, however different milk alternate options, resembling almond milk, should not, as a result of they don’t have sufficient vitamins to satisfy USDA requirements, mentioned Gross, who’s an affiliate scientist within the Division of Inhabitants, Household and Reproductive Well being and a WIC program nutritionist.
The WIC packages are tailor-made for every participant, and members can select what kind of milk they need. “Nobody is compelled to drink milk alternate options,” Gross mentioned.
The USDA is accepting public feedback on the proposed modifications till Feb. 21, 2023.
Stefanik claimed {that a} proposed rule would restrict milk for members of a federal meals program for ladies and kids.
The USDA has proposed modifications to this system, which incorporates reductions within the quantity of fluid milk obtainable to most program recipients, prompted by new dietary tips in addition to suggestions from the Nationwide Academies of Science, Engineering, and Drugs. The reductions are additionally in step with what WIC recipients buy by means of this system.
Stefanik additionally made a prediction that the proposed rule would result in extra “compelled vegan juice consumption.” We don’t fact-check predictions and that assertion is exterior the scope of this ruling. It ought to be famous, nevertheless, that based mostly on the obtainable proof, WIC has not and won’t drive milk alternate options on anybody.
